This topic has been archived. It cannot be replied.
-
枫下拾英 / 乐韵书香 / 还是对C Kleiber的DVDs（now on sales at HMV）不死心。请教各位大侠，这两盘该买哪一个，值得买吗：New Year's Concert 1992, Vienna (1992)和Carlos Kleiber - Beethoven Symphonies 4 and 7？注：偶已经请回了Herbert von Karajan的Beethoven - The Symphonies Boxset。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
{72}
(#2771179@0)
-
the second one. you can borrow the first one from 朔爷
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771181@0)
-
这个什么爷的真惨,就这么一盘DVD??
-zchzw(一本正经);
2006-2-8
(#2771210@0)
-
其实, 就买一盘Kleiber的Beethoven 的第无和第七的CD 就行了. DVD 没啥好看的.
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771193@0)
-
CD也别买了, 就听96.3经常播~;-)
-li_ao(抬着混);
2006-2-8
(#2771197@0)
-
那不行, 96.3 一次只播一个乐章.
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771203@0)
-
另外再买一盘Furtwangler指挥的贝多芬第九(EMI Great Recordings)
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771200@0)
-
怎么个好法？Much better or different than Herbert Von Karajan's version?
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771307@0)
-
my opinion--THE best, even if it's mono
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771484@0)
-
In my opinion, Karajan got the shape; Furtwangler got the soul.
-hubeir(Hubeir);
2006-2-16
(#2786627@0)
-
Are you saying that C Kleiber’s conducting is not really VISUALLY enjoyable? He’s good only because the way he conducts the orchestra to interpret a piece?
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771208@0)
-
stick with Lang Lang for dramatic visual effects. ;)
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771214@0)
-
seriously, if you go for visual effect, then buy the first one.
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771217@0)
-
"the way he conducts the orchestra to interpret a piece", that is the only way thing that matters for a conductor's reputation in the long run
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771239@0)
-
真喜欢的话. both are very good~they deserve your money for sure~
-li_ao(抬着混);
2006-2-8
(#2771194@0)
-
我是一直"相当"小看维也纳爱乐的新年音乐会~ -njzy("王朔"); 2.6 19:33 (#2767417@0)Reply
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-8
(#2771206@0)
-
不能删了
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771353@0)
-
就是不知道会不会喜欢才问的呀。犹豫买第二张是因为不想重复（刚买了Herbert Von Karajan的版本），现在还没到钻研版本的阶段。犹豫买第一张是怀疑。。。。。。得，偶再想想。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771277@0)
-
把有限的资金，投入到无限的作品中去。要买就买10大交响乐团+10大指挥+10作曲家+10大交响乐。满足了这样组合的dvd才值得买。例如，柏林交响乐团由卡拉扬指挥的贝多芬的第5交响曲，而不是XXX的星条旗永不落。。。
-noproblem(大可以);
2006-2-8
(#2771338@0)
-
“柏林交响乐团由卡拉扬指挥的贝多芬的第5交响曲” －－－第１到第９偶昨儿刚入了啊。$69.99全套，比amazon的要便宜。Salesman说过些天价格会调上去。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771363@0)
-
哇赛！我好像找到了library。。。:-)
-noproblem(大可以);
2006-2-8
(#2771421@0)
-
“要买就买10大交响乐团+10大指挥+10作曲家+10大交响乐。满足了这样组合的dvd才值得买。” －－－大哥，原则上sounds like it。但是，偶们现在须要的是details details details，比如说ASIN＃之类的。；）
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771376@0)
-
我转贴的DG 75张收齐了吗? ;-)
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771351@0)
-
Where where where again?
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-8
(#2771380@0)
-
Bravo! Bravo! Bravo!~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~看Carlos Kleiber指挥92年维也纳爱乐新年音乐会的观众疯掉了，偶也疯掉了。这辈子看这么一场演出也值得了，附庸风雅就附庸风雅吧，已经顾不上那么许多了。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-25
(#2806527@0)
-
想当一些钢琴曲, 除了用人名搜寻了一些, 请大家推荐一些具体的, 请用E文曲名儿.
-berg(伯格);
2006-2-8
(#2771298@0)
-
Beethoven Piano Concert No.4 Pollini(P), Abbado, Berliner, 1994
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771339@0)
-
Beethoven Piano Concert No.5 皇帝 Brendel, Levine, Chicago 1983 live
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771340@0)
-
Brahms Piano concerto No.1 Curzon, LSO, Szell 1962
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771342@0)
-
Chopin piano Concerto No. 1 Artur Rubinstein，London Symphony Orchestra， Sir John Barbirolli
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771343@0)
-
Mozart Piano Concertos Nos 26 'Coronation' Friedrich Gulda，Nikolaus Harnoncourt
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771345@0)
-
Rachmaninoff Piano Concertos Nos.3 Janis/Dorati/Mercury
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771347@0)
-
Tchaikovsky Piano Concerto No. 1 Sviatoslav Teofilovich Richter，Leningrad Philharmonic Orchestra，Yevgeny Mravinsky
-pipibug(皮皮巴格golf);
2006-2-8
(#2771348@0)
-
3q3q, 皮皮巴格. ^_^
-berg(伯格);
2006-2-8
(#2771358@0)
-
请回了Carlos Kleiber – Mozart: Symphony No. 36 “Linz”; Brahms: Symphony No. 2。It's now on 2/$40。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-14
(#2783689@0)
-
你如此频繁地去请, 让我有一种犯罪感~~~
-klassische(老音乐迷);
2006-2-14
(#2783750@0)
-
醉得还不轻~~~;-)
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-14
(#2783776@0)
-
ID被盗？ 呵呵
-lifesucks(换个ID继续混);
2006-2-14
(#2783988@0)
-
这个Kleiber是不同凡响。看完一个曲子偶才敢喘一口气。这老头儿绝对是个完美主义者，每个抑扬顿挫回转他都看得很紧。看他指挥，好像看好几个人：芭蕾舞演员、耍太极的、魔术师、音乐评论家、欣赏家、哈姆雷特。。。。。。接着看。
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-19
(#2792459@0)
-
俩忽悠绝版现在翻出来才明白点儿啥似的：
-eglispa(一呵呵);
2006-2-19
(#2792598@0)